Homeowner guide · Paperwork and tanks
Renting vs Buying a Water Heater
Plenty of Ontario homes came with a rental water heater that nobody remembers signing up for. Before you decide to keep it, buy it out or replace it, it helps to know how these arrangements work.
Phone only · a plumber answers, not a form
- Licensed plumbers (ask us for details)
- Quote settled before tools come out
- We tidy up after every job
- Aurora & York Region
Jump to a section
- How rentals work
- Reading your contract
- Buyouts and removal
- Comparing over time
Quick checklist
Have these on hand
- Flange plunger and cup plunger
- Hand auger (25 ft is plenty for a sink)
- Shop vac with a wet filter
- Plumber tape and spare washers
Stop and call when
- Water is coming through a ceiling
- A drain is backing up into the basement
- There is a gas odour: get outside before phoning anyone
- A fitting will not loosen without twisting the pipe behind it
How rentals work
With a rental, a company owns the tank in your basement and bills you a monthly fee, often on your utility bill or a separate invoice. The fee typically covers the equipment and some level of repair or replacement if it fails. When a home is sold, the rental usually transfers to the new owner, which is why many buyers inherit one.
Owning means you pay for the heater and installation up front, then cover any repairs and the eventual replacement yourself. There is no monthly charge for the equipment.
Reading your contract
Start by finding the paperwork. If you do not have it, call the company named on the sticker on the tank and ask for a copy. Look for:
- The current monthly rate and how it can change over time.
- What repairs and replacements are included.
- The buyout terms, and how the buyout amount is calculated.
- Fees or conditions for removing the tank and returning it.
- Notice requirements before cancelling.
Buyouts and removal
If you decide to own, you have two paths. You can buy out the existing tank from the rental company, or you can install your own new heater and return the rental unit. Each company has its own process. Some require you to arrange the return, some collect the tank, and some charge for that service. Get the details in writing before any work is booked.
We can install an owned heater and set the old tank aside for pickup, but we will not cancel your rental contract for you. That conversation is between you and the provider.
Comparing over time
To compare honestly, put the numbers side by side. Add up what you have paid and expect to pay in rental fees over the years you plan to stay in the house. Compare that with the cost of buying and installing a heater, plus a realistic allowance for repairs. Consider the age of the current tank too; buying out an old unit may not make sense if it is close to the end of its life.
Ask for written quotes for a new installation and the rental company's buyout figure, then decide on facts. Our guide on water heater lifespan helps judge the old tank, and tankless versus tank helps choose a replacement. For hard water concerns that affect any heater, read hard water in York Region.
Whatever you decide, keep every letter, invoice and confirmation in one folder. Rental disputes often come down to dates and documents, and a tidy file settles them quickly.
Aurora customers often ask
Can I just return my rental water heater?
Usually yes, according to the terms of your contract. Expect possible removal or return fees, and confirm the process with the rental company first.
Is renting or owning cheaper?
It depends on your contract rate, the age of the tank and how long you plan to stay. Compare the written figures for your situation.
Will you install a heater while I still have a rental?
We can install an owned heater, but you need to handle the rental contract and the return arrangements with your provider.